[Infowarrior] - GAO Study Contradicts Counterfeit Claims

[Richard Forno]

GAO Study Contradicts Counterfeit Claims

http://www.michaelgeist.ca/content/view/1922/125/

Thursday May 03, 2007

I appeared before the Standing Committee on Industry, Science and Technology
on Wednesday to discuss counterfeiting (following on my appearance last week
before the Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security).  My
opening remarks are posted below - they focused primarily on the need to
obtain more accurate data (I cited the inconsistent data associated with
camcording) and to separate the counterfeiting issue from copyright reform
(I argued that the inclusion of issues such as ratification of the WIPO
Internet treaties is hampering progress on the serious counterfeiting
problems).

Interestingly, just after the hearing I was alerted to a new U.S. study
[PDF] from the Government Accountability Office on U.S. border enforcement
activities against counterfeiting.  The report is a must-read for people
focused on this issue as it highlights two very important things.  First,
notwithstanding the claims that Canada must dramatically reform the powers
afforded to our border services to address counterfeiting, the GAO study
demonstrates that even countries like the U.S. are struggling with this
issue as it points to a lack of data and coordination within the U.S.

Second, the data contained in the GAO report suggests that the claims
associated with counterfeiting are massively overstated.  The Industry
Committee previously heard from witnesses who noted that there have claims
that 5 to 7 percent of world trade involves counterfeit products (some even
argue that is growing).  The GAO study points to the U.S. Compliance Measure
Program, a statistical sampling program, that randomly selects shipments to
check for their compliance with the law, including IP laws.  Of 287,000
inspected shipments from 2000 - 2005, IP violations were only found in 0.06
percent of shipments - less than one tenth of one percent.  This large
random sample suggests that counterfeit products are actually only found in
a tiny percentage of shipments.  Moreover, the GAO notes that despite
increases in IP seizures, the value of those seizures in 2005 represented
only 0.02 percent of the total value of imports of goods in product
categories that are likely to involve IP protection.  In other words, the
evidence from an independent, U.S. government sponsored agency points to a
far different reality from that presented to the two parliamentary
committees investigating counterfeiting.

< - >

http://www.michaelgeist.ca/content/view/1922/125/