[Infowarrior] - Judge Tells FBI To Explain Its Overly-Broad Use Of FOIA Exceptions

[Richard Forno]

Judge Tells FBI To Explain Its Overly-Broad Use Of FOIA Exceptions

from the Occupy-J.E.-Hoover dept

As we recently covered, a judge had ordered the CIA to explain its ridiculous FOIA response tactics. The CIA had, with a straight face, first claimed it could ONLY produce hard copies of digital files from an internal security journal. Then, it said the only way it could create digital files was by printing out the files and re-scanning them. The judge noted in her order that Congress recognized government agencies would be reluctant to hand over documents to the public, which is why it directed agencies to make every reasonable effort to accommodate requests. This, of course, was not what the legislators had in mind when they crafted the Freedom of Information Act. 

Now, it's the FBI being asked by a judge to explain its overuse of FOIA exemptions to withhold documents. This time, it's the (in)famous Ryan Shapiro suing our government for access to information. Shapiro is well-known by the FBI, which has attempted to shut down the prolific requester by simply refusing his FOIA requests. It justifies this violation of the FOIA by claiming (somewhat accurately) that Shapiro is utilizing a "mosaic" method to gain access to information the FBI clearly wants to keep hidden. The theory is that with enough overlapping requests, responses will turn up either different documents or inconsistent redactions, thus revealing potentially sensitive information.

< - >

http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20140317/16151426602/judge-tells-fbi-to-explain-its-overly-broad-use-foia-exceptions.shtml

---
Just because i'm near the punchbowl doesn't mean I'm also drinking from it.