[Infowarrior] - SOPA vote: Well, there's always next year

[Richard Forno]

(Update:  I beleive they're resuming markup on 12/21, which suggests Smith is trying to get this thing out of committee in the dead of night and/or while everyone is drinking eggnog and looking skywards for Santa.  -- rick)

SOPA vote: Well, there's always next year
by Declan McCullagh December 16, 2011 2:15 PM PST  

http://news.cnet.com/8301-31921_3-57344469-281/sopa-vote-well-theres-always-next-year/

A marathon congressional hearing on the Stop Online Piracy Act, which detoured through discussions of Twitter-borne insults and the popular meme "The Internet is for Porn," will resume sometime in 2012.

The delay was a victory for opponents of SOPA, who pulled off a quasi-filibuster by repeatedly presenting critiques of the controversial Hollywood-backed copyright legislation and offering over 70 amendments that sought to rewrite individual portions of the legislation.
 
Rep. Lamar Smith (R-Tex.), the head of the House Judiciary committee chairman and author of SOPA -- also known as Hollywood's favorite House Republican -- initially had promised to hold a final vote on his bill as soon as possible

"Yes, I have every intention of going forward today, tomorrow, and however long it takes," Smith said yesterday.

But Smith's plan was derailed by a dogged group of opponents, who managed to pull off this legislative upset even though they were badly outnumbered on the committee by allies of the Motion Picture Association, the Recording Industry Association of America, and other SOPA proponents. (See CNET's FAQ on SOPA.)

Rep. Zoe Lofgren, a California Democrat who represents part of Silicon Valley, launched the first procedural fusillade as soon as the hearing began yesterday by insisting on her right to have the entire text of SOPA read aloud by the committee's clerk.

An unhappy Smith said that the reading "will take 45 minutes to an hour."

Rep. Howard Berman, a California Democrat whose district is adjacent to Hollywood, asked Smith if "a motion to dispense with the reading is in order."

"Such a motion regrettably is not in order," Smith replied, and the markup session ground to a halt for an hour.

After nearly 12 hours of debate in which both sides seemed to be repeating themselves more often than not, Smith reluctantly adjourned yesterday's session until 10 a.m. ET today. Meanwhile, his plans for an accelerated vote, without convening even one hearing exploring SOPA's technical aspects, slammed into an unexpected obstacle: a last-minute deal on a spending bill to fund the federal government through September 2012. The House approved it today.

Nobody else in Washington, D.C., except perhaps the large copyright holders who helped to advance SOPA so far so quickly, wanted to stick around any longer on a Friday afternoon in December. Smith eventually recognized the obvious and said: "We stand adjourned."

One bizarre detour came when Rep. Steve King (R-Iowa), was, perhaps, a bit too honest in assessing one of his colleague's presenting style. King tweeted: "We are debating the Stop Online Piracy Act and Shiela Jackson [sic] has so bored me that I'm killing time by surfing the Internet."

That would be Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee, a Texas Democrat named the "meanest" member of Congress by Washingtonian magazine, who responded by calling the tweet "offensive." The debate the future of Internet copyright law paused to discuss the important question of whether who, if anyone, had impugned the integrity of a member of the committee and how it could be rectified.

The second unusual detour came when Rep. Jared Polis, a Colorado Democrat who presumably knows his way around the Internet better than any other member of Congress (he founded BlueMountainArts.com), brought up pornography.

A "high percentage" of the Internet's use is for porn, he said. It's "a pornographer's wet dream!"

Polis then offered an amendment that would stop the Justice Department from using SOPA's vast powers to aid adult industry businesses who happen to hold valid copyrights. "Pornography should not be the focus of the attorney general's protection," he said.

This was a brilliant tactical maneuver. First, it delayed discussions while members of the august Judiciary committee wrangled with how to handle this unusual conversational detour. Second, it put Smith, a conservative Republican whose district is largely Texas Hill Country, on the defensive. 

"We need to respect the discretion of federal law enforcement officials," Smith said.

Third -- and this may have been the point of the entire exercise -- it gave Polis an excuse to insert the full lyrics of the popular Internet meme "The Internet is for Porn" into the official congressional hearing record.

More to come...


---
Just because i'm near the punchbowl doesn't mean I'm also drinking from it.