[Infowarrior] - Apple Isn't Even Bothering To Lie Anymore

[Richard Forno]

Apple Isn't Even Bothering To Lie Anymore
Michael Arrington
TechCrunch.com
Monday, October 5, 2009 11:52 PM

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/10/06/AR2009100600470_pf.html
I mean, seriously.

Apple's chief complaint against the Google Voice application was "The  
application has not been approved because, as submitted for review, it  
appears to alter the iPhone?s distinctive user experience by replacing  
the iPhone?s core mobile telephone functionality and Apple user  
interface with its own user interface for telephone calls¿"

And that's ok, because we all know that the real reason Apple won't  
let Google Voice through is that they are scared out of their mind  
that Android and Google Voice will eat their iPhone lunch over the  
long term. Apple can't win the fight over the long term, but they sure  
are willing to say and do anything in the short term to stop the  
advance of Google.

But you'd think they'd at least be consistent and apply the same  
arguments to other third party apps. At least until this whole FCC  
thing blows over.

But Skype's calling app, which uses Wifi, is totally fine. And  
yesterday, the Vonage iPhone app, which seems to be just as much of an  
issue as Google Voice based on that quote at the top, got the green  
light, too.

Users can use Wifi or cellular minutes, and have to open the Vonage  
application to make calls. They'll save a bundle on international  
calling.

Of course, it's hard to argue that Vonage doesn't "alter the iPhone?s  
distinctive user experience by replacing the iPhone?s core mobile  
telephone functionality and Apple user interface with its own user  
interface for telephone calls."

But really, I'm not even sure anyone is paying attention at this  
point. If you care, the truth is this ¿ Apple isn't threatened by  
Vonage. The smart thing would have been to reject their app anyway, to  
stay consistent. But unless someone actually forces Apple to play by  
the rules, why should they?

Yeah, I know. Apple Fanboys can unleash hell on us now in the comments.


© 2009 TechCrunch