[Infowarrior] - Top Internet Providers Cool to RIAA 3-Strikes Plan

[Richard Forno]

Top Internet Providers Cool to RIAA 3-Strikes Plan
By David Kravets EmailJanuary 05, 2009 | 2:43:15 PMCategories: RIAA  
Litigation

http://blog.wired.com/27bstroke6/2009/01/draft-verizon-o.html

Two weeks after the Recording Industry Association of America  
announced it had struck deals with top internet service providers to  
cut off unrepentant music sharers, not a single major ISP will cop to  
agreeing to the ambitious scheme, and one top broadband company says  
it's not on board.

The RIAA's announcement came as it revealed it was closing down its  
massive litigation campaign, which has targeted more than 30,000  
individuals for allegedly sharing copyrighted music on the internet.  
Instead of federal lawsuits, the RIAA claims it would now rely on a  
series of accords it had reached with "leading" internet service  
providers, in which the ISPs have agreed to terminate customers the  
RIAA catches uploading three times, the association said.

But when contacted by Threat Level, none of the leading ISPs  
acknowledged any such deal.  "We are not working with them on this,"  
Verizon spokeswoman Ellen Yu said in a telephone interview. Verizon,  
based in New York, has 8.5 million broadband subscribers, making it  
the fourth largest ISP by customer base.

Comcast, the nation's second largest ISP, declined to comment, and  
referred inquiries to the National Cable & Telecommunications  
Association. The group's vice president, Brian Dietz, said he could  
not confirm any deals between the RIAA and his association's members,  
but "we look forward to working constructively with the recording  
industry and other content providers."

The NCTA represents dozens of cable internet providers. Neither AT&T  
nor Verizon are represented by the group.

AT&T, the nation's No. 1 internet service provider with about 14.8  
million customers, declined comment through a spokesman. Time Warner  
Cable, Cox Communications and Charter Communications did not return  
repeated phone calls for comment.

But the RIAA says it really has negotiated an enforcement deal with  
large ISPs. It just can't identify members of its coalition of the  
willing.

"All I can tell you right now is that we have an agreement on  
principle with several leading ISPs but not all, and the agreement on  
principle is confidential," RIAA spokeswoman Cara Duckworth said in an  
e-mail.

The recording industry began targeting individual file sharers five  
years ago, suing about 30,000 alleged copyright scofflaws. Most of the  
cases settled out of court for a few thousand dollars.

Only one case went to trial, which was ultimately declared a mistrial  
after a federal judge said he erred when he instructed the jury that  
"making available" copyrighted music on the internet amounted to  
unauthorized distribution — or copyright infringement — regardless of  
whether actual downloading by others was shown.

The mistrial decision nullified a $222,000 jury verdict against Jammie  
Thomas of Minnesota for sharing 24 songs on the Kazaa file sharing  
network.

The RIAA's latest plan of enforcement with the ISPs, if it comes to  
fruition, is also under attack as it only targets uploaders (.pdf).

A Thomas retrial is set for March, as the RIAA said it was continuing  
with cases that were already in the legal pipeline.